So, now we have all had time to use our little soap savers, here is what we think.
Kid 1: Gets you clean but does not make enough lather. It makes the soap really mushy.
Kid 2: I hate it, doesn't soap off (not sure what that means) the soap doesn't come out enough. It feels really uncomfortable.
Kid 3: No I don't like it at all. I can barely get any soap out of it.
Me: The cloth never dries, so it is cold and feels a little gross at first. Sometimes it lathers, sometimes not.It does make it much easier to hold on to the soap.
Hubby: Hasn't touched it that I know of.
So our overall rating is 2 thumbs down. (In other words, if I were you I would not bother making these.)
It was a nice thought, I guess, but it is not really doing the job like the manufactured ones. I am sure that what they make their covers out of was made specifically to dry and let the lather out. Good job Johnson and Johnson!